Showing posts with label literary criticism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label literary criticism. Show all posts

Thursday, April 27, 2023

Mysticism versus Psychosis

 Mysticism versus Psychosis


Mysticism is the practice of tactical experience from which transcendent knowledge can be gained. To the mystic, all forms of knowledge are transcendent. To the mystic, knowledge is a limit that must be pushed forward by tactical experience. 


The mystic stands on time like Christ walking on water. The goal of the mystic is to transcend time, to find truths beyond time, to know the eternal and the infinite through direct experience achieved through altered states of consciousness.


The question of whether or not mystics induce psychosis in order to see things from a novel vantage is of particular interest to someone who likes to think about mysticism and has experienced psychosis.


The major difference between a mystic and a psychotic is that the mystic is not harried by the experience. So, when mystics would deprive themselves of sleep and/or take substances to induce an altered state of consciousness, they were doing so with the intent of inducing a mystical/psychotic experience. 


Psychotics tend to have delusions related to themselves. Mystics have imaginative experiences that relate to something larger than themselves. Mystics are those who believe experience is an experiment; that their experience of the world, no matter how difficult to communicate, can be communicated using specific types of reference. Psychiatry has a term for this called “delusions of reference.” The mystic can operate in the delusional headspace while simultaneously compartmentalizing it when dealing with others. 


This requires holding two contradictory truths as equally true: Just because someone else can’t see it doesn’t mean it isn’t real, the real is a product of the consensus delusion of the majority of others.


The mystic, ostensibly, isn’t harmed by the experience. The psychotic is, perhaps, because the psychosis lasts for too long and starts to condition the brain to think in a way that isn’t particularly helpful for living in a society of those with other notions of the real. It seems to impact executive functioning and requires a relearning of reality the longer the psychotic episode lasts. In other words, psychosis can cause brain damage.


Ultimately, the mystic can use the experience in a way that is beneficial to self and other while the psychotic harms both self and other. There may not be much more difference than that.



Wednesday, April 26, 2023

Post-Cubism

A lot of my approach to the art of poetry is based on a “box within a box” typography I heard once in a poetry class. The poet’s name was Yi Sang; the poem was called "Supermarket"; his approach was Cubist. Shortly thereafter, I began developing a Cubist approach to writing poems. Much of this was visual and you can see it play out in the Gospel of Echo. In The Book of the Damned, the approach is more subtle; in The Devourer, it is less subtle because each poem is laid out in a textbox. The "uterus within utero" poem in TGOE is a direct homage.


For me, Cubism allowed for a subtle critique on “naming as encapsulation.” A lot of Sang’s work (as I understand it) details the cruelty of this artificial form of segmentation that undergirds even our relationship to ourselves and especially our relationship to our environment. 


In carrying forth a legacy, you want to do so without making it an awkward robbery or appropriation. Sang was already being influenced by Western writing which is how he got to Cubism. It was part of a cross-cultural exchange. What Yi Sang did with cubism is considerably more interesting than what English language poets had done up to that point.


So, Yi Sang’s work was pretty foundational to developing a Cubist poetics for the English language.


The Temporality of Fear

 Let’s assume the most primordial form of fear is fright, an immediate fear as in jumpscares. Something triggers in the amygdala and it’s strong enough to condition. But another form of fear can do the same: Dread. How do you effectively instill a sense of dread? Well, properly thought of, dread is fear projected into the future from the past. The dread must be strong enough to penetrate the merely now and go beyond in both directions at once. It has the power to condition via rejection and prevention. It has the power to penetrate the barrier between now and then or thence to create something even more terrorizing: Panic. 


Sunday, April 23, 2023

An Ontology of the Future

 1. The Future doesn’t exist


The future doesn’t exist, but it surely will. Our predictions of the future are related to our careful study of yesterday’s data. The future is little more than a past that hasn’t happened yet. It unfolds from the past. The now is a temporary state created by your mind to remain attentive. In this essay, the now is irrelevant. Only the future has import here. And to understand it at all, we must dredge through the past. 


2.


The now is relevant only insofar as it demarcates past from future. The now is a past passing out of being while the future is now yet to be. Instead of “existing” the future “exists” as disarticulated abstractions forming potentialities that are “collapsed back” into seed form. For an example, Jones is a person, but is a person Jones? Potentially. We only know that the person could be Jones. Once we have a complete set of all the potential people a person could be, we have a general sense of the possible future. 


3.


What can be known exists in knowledge. Therefore, it is the past. It is also limited. You can never dredge new knowledge just from what is known. To venture beyond what is known is to commit to the future. To know is to become stagnant. The truth has killed more dreams than God. 


4. Ontological guessing


An ontology of the future would consist of this metric:

[impossible/certain]

[unlikely/likely]

[formally undecidable/50-50]


Once you step out of time and into the realm of potentials, you need composite objects (like Coins) that have a front and a back or are, defined by their contradiction like Heraclitus’s nature. 


4. 


Many futures compete to come into being. Not all of them will. However, the competition among futures follows the same trajectory as evolutionary selection (which is not entirely reducible to natural selection). At some point, humanity surpassed natural selection and suddenly, we started making decisions based on aesthetics.


The futures competing to come into being are yours and mine. Our futures fight against other futures in a competitive matrix of American cancel energy. Very few futures bubble beyond the surface in the cosmic froth that kills them. 


5.


We should be more intentional about nurturing the futures of our fellow humans, less willing to cancel futures, and respect the role aesthetics plays in evolution.


Thursday, April 20, 2023

Three Eyes

For Aristotle, the eyes were passive, wholly, taking in reality. For Plato, the eyes were both passive and active, creating an admixture. The schizophrenic is the third option, what I call "bright eyes". The schizophrenic's eyes are active, sometimes, obliterating reality entirely. 

Tuesday, April 4, 2023

Is an Interpretation Really a Poem?

I don't know, call me old fashioned, but in my day, the act of writing poetry meant leaving the reader room for interpretation the fascist new American aesthetic is dangerous to a society that is still healing from past trauma. Such technology could cause unintended deaths that cost thousands of dollars to settle. If we don't get a hold of the tort system, we'll just sue ourselves into oblivion. Even the poor need money.

While most of you are probably excited about the New American poetics, I find it deeply concerning. Earlier poets often withheld their own agency to allow the reader a space to grow. The New American poetics is as closed as a poem can be. There's barely room for interpretation. The poem is an interpretation.

Essentially, the New American poetics thinks you're so stupid that it has to tell you what to do. You can't figure it out for yourself, idiot, so here's a fiction to think about.

Poetry is not interpretation. Poetry demands interpretation. The New American poetics puts everything in the wrong place. 

Sunday, March 26, 2023

Three Types of Reality

 The zeroth order of reality is fundamentally unknowable to our senses. It's rules can only be derived through the extension of our senses into domains our senses cannot perceive. Our knowledge of this reality is thus limited to our engineering capacity to manipulate it. The rules of this reality must be derived from the observations we can make. At some point, we can make no observations at all. This domain seems to undergird the reality we can perceive, the material world.

Hence, the first order of reality is assigned to the material. Things in space. Matter. Even complex processes like storms. The only reason this is more real than the zeroth order is because more people have access to it. We can discuss objects in space with decent certainty that we're referring to the same thing. This is not true of the second-order of reality, the representational or symbolic.

Numbers, words, stories, everything enters the second order of the real. However, I cannot provide you with direct access to this reality. Hence, it is second-order. I must translate it by way of second-order objects. This is confusing. It causes confusion. It also reduces confusion. 

It creates more confusion when you realize that first-order and zeroth-order objects can be moved into the second-order where they begin to operate like metaphor. In fact, anything from any order can be moved into the second order of reality to operate like a metaphor. Events can become metaphors. Even people, problematically, can become metaphors. A separation between these two orders of reality is thus necessary. 

Lossy Compression, The Counting Argument, and Ontology

 Are three things I don't care about. The question of ontology is pointless to me. I can't even perform a combinatorial proof if you asked me. I've never in my life been interested in compression as a computer skill. So the idea that these three ideas would all come together came from a very different impulse. Anti-theory. 

I couldn't put my finger on it, but the abuse and misappropriation of theory to sieve information from literary texts seemed beyond the pale of any reasonable thing a person would do. Why?

Because from my perspective, all they were doing was mapping one idea to another and the utility of this was not apparent. Anti-theory seemed to allow me a baseline to critique this impulse so that is why these three things were important to me. I was also interested in the abuse of theory for racial, gender, and other forms discrimination and prejudice. So, if we're racist, we map an individual person to a biased image that we've created of them and see that image instead of the person. Very intuitive. No one else was thinking this way until Hofstedter.

So, here I am, a kid with knowledge of Western ontology because he literally despised it learning linear algebra on a support board for amateur coders in the FreeBasic community when a conversation about Jews erupted.

That's it. That's the moment. Message board. Coders. Lossy compression. Anti-semitism.

The Scene

There's a group of four of us who participate in a thread where we trade code making pretty pictures with pure math. I'm way behind all of these guys. The one dude is an Australian physicist named Richard. Another is a Scottish mathematician by the handle Dodicat, and there is a third man who suffers from mental illness but enjoys math. He decides to discuss his theory on Jews which I won't get into here. Suffice it to say he was wrong.

AT THE SAME EXACT TIME, this guy is also attempting to explain how you can compress information losslessly. Richard explains to him that this is impossible and the proof he supplies is the counting argument. I made the connection to ontology vis a vis a mapping argument.




Tuesday, March 21, 2023

Is Intuition Statistics?

 A man is in a bedroom with no windows. He never leaves. Three times a day, a woman enters the room, feeds him, and tells him the weather. After one year, the woman is about to tell him what's going on when he says, "It's raining."

"You're right!" she says, "How did you know?"

The answer is: The neural net. The man may not be aware of it, but he's sensing subtle changes in the barometric pressure along with other indicators that we readily dismiss. Eventually, he can guess with some consistency whether or not it's raining.

This is what you call "knowing without knowing you know" or "knowing without knowing why". It's what we call intuition or our instincts.

Essentially, your brain creates a statistical model of all the times the woman said it was raining and your body sensed the subtle changes in the atmosphere, and this gave you the ability to predict, within a certain degree of accuracy (because false positives will happen) if it was raining.

Food for thought.


Sunday, March 19, 2023

The Ancient Mysteries of Greece

  Mystery religions existed in Ancient Greece, but by then, they would have been considered "Old Tyme Religion". The philosophers didn't think much of them and the promises they made of immortality in death, but they offered something else too. The ability to become one with your deity or mythic figure. Mostly, these figures were demi-human. Orpheus, as an example, had a mystery school. The only thing that survives to modern day are the initiations of the Freemasons and all that which was derived from it. We also have occult practices that engage in this sort of intentional ritual combat to connect one's self to a higher power. In the case of the Abramelin, you want to gain contact with your Guardian Angel. The Freemasons re-enact the sacred story of Hiram Abiff, the mythical architect of the Holy Temple in Jerusalem.

It is extremely likely that the schools revolved around trades. The Masonic school would have been a closed circuit to all but Masons until the order was opened up to others. The Masons taught things like sacred geometry because those things are very interesting to Masons. The initiation would have likely taken place when a young man was ready to commit to the trade of masonry. So, think late teens and early 20's traditionally.

The Greek mystery schools would have likely draw older adults who were in need of a psychic transformation. The idea was that they would die to their former selves and be reborn with a psychic fresh start. The details of the schools were kept entirely secret and nothing remains. But we know that those who paid to have these rituals performed would, like the Freemasons, relive the story of the mythological figure. So, with Orpheus, you would have to relive that tragedy. The idea was to simulate it and connect yourself with the gifts of the demi-god. A poet or musician might be interested in the Orphic rites. They might learn things about musical technique as well. Become attuned to certain principles. It is likely that drugs were involved, sex too maybe. 

For Masons, you might learn Pythagorean principles, mathematical principles, and many concepts that would have been considered occult or secret. Lots of things relevant to masonry as a trade. 

Personalizing our connection to these heroic figures was thus and essential part of providing meaning to the lives of ancient and modern people. 

Western Ontology and Lossy Compression

Existence

 Existence and non-existence. What "exists" and what doesn't? Western Ontology wants to bifurcate, but that isn't the only way to manage this information. It becomes possible to talk about different types of non-existence. For example, a number doesn't "exist" in the same way that two pineapples do, but it does exist. So it becomes necessary to draw a distinction between the way that a pineapple exists, and the way that we count pineapples. It later becomes possible to imagine something impossible like infinity pineapples. Infinity pineapples does not exist in the same way that two pineapples do. Two pineapples are within the realm of possibility while infinity pineapples wouldn't leave room for anyone else unless they were inside an even bigger infinity (which is possible).

We will be arguing that Western ontology wants to say everything either exists or it does not and this is a blunter tool producing less useful results than an approach that didn't.

Metaphysics

Western metaphysics is concerned with ontology which is the study of what is. Its impulse is to take the myriad things in the first order of material existence and then map them back to second-order existence things like numbers.

Can you do this? The answer is yes. But there is one rule. The number of objects on the first-order side must be identical to the number of objects on the second-order side (see Quine). Elsewise, you end up with information loss.

Information loss is not intrinsically "bad". It just needs to be kept in mind. 

So, let's say I write a book using every word in the dictionary at least once. Is this book "the same as" the dictionary? No. The book is out of order and does not contain the information we need. When we map, we need to map everything identically, and that includes the structure and the sequence. We have lost considerable information when we wrote our book. We added information as well.

Metaphysics in the Western tradition wants to be able to map the material back onto the "numeric" or "symbolic". Ultimately, this is the foundation of metaphor, language, religion, ritual, meaning, and everything. It becomes dysfunctional, however, when we forget that the two sides need to be even. 

I think Quine's work produces the best scholarship on the matter from an analytic perspective. Following closely with Quine would likely produce better results than I can produce. 

Categories and Sets

A category or set exists in the second-order. However, it is drawn off a first-order observation. For example, if I see a furry animal wagging its tail, I'd readily associate that with the category of "dog". Does "dog" exist as a stable non-dividable concept? Well, there was a time when dogs did not exist. Now they do. There will be a time when dogs do not exist. Perhaps the dog evolves stronger hind legs, and learns to walk upright and we can pay our furry friends to do our taxes.

The dog is not stable. The category is an effort to "freeze" the dog and it's useful for certain goals. The effort, however, is to encapsulate. 

Compression

We call "lossy compression" lossy because you lose information. In other words, what specifically I am discussing as a misguided effort of Western ontology is useful for making certain types of files smaller. Imagine a picture that is 400x400 of your face. I can compress the image by stripping 0s at the end of numbers (lossless compression) or I can fudge the information making it blurrier. The overall quality of the picture may not be severely reduced, but there is information loss. Why? Because you have mapped N elements to fewer than N elements.

When we discuss something in categorical terms, we do something similar. The category, as a second-order "thing" is "less real" than a material object (a first-order thing). It tells you less. One can imagine an image becoming blurrier and blurrier as information is mapped to fewer second-order symbols. (In this case, second-order merely means derived from. In terms of symbolic logic, second-order means symbolic, first-order means material, and everything else is unreal for now). 

In order to work successfully with a category, one must consider that it is a second-order thing, that there will be information loss, potentially information superimposed, and finally, could be indicative of cultural bias.

Where to go from here?

  • Category charging - The cultural impulse to emotionally charge a category (good/evil). Also, the impulse to condition taboos or reinforce by category. When we discuss people in terms of categories, this can be used as a weapon.
  • Category discrimination - Is Derridean asymmetry contributing to the manufacture of bias?


Friday, March 17, 2023

Is the Manciple's Tale Baseless Fearmongering? Yes!

The original essay is here. This basically explains the ending in terms of the Rhetoric of Drugs.

The choice to end this essay on the Manciple's Tale served two purposes. The first was that it was a self-negating. It is a story, but it's a story about not telling stories. This makes it similar to the Rhetoric of Drugs:

  • The story is "pointed at itself" in a very specific way
  • The story is meant to produce an effect
  • The story has a zero truth value
  • The sentence imposed on the crow is false
So, the story mirrors the Rhetoric of Drugs insofar as it's designed to produce a feeling of fear. It's about being very carful what you say, even when you're right. 

Now, I can tell a different story about someone who rats on a cheating spouse and is rewarded with $20,000 grand because they're a private investigator and that's their job. This would essentially render the fear inert or at least give the individual the sense that quietude was not the only possible solution to this problem.

The Maniciple's Tale is anti-narrative narrative.  The function of the narrative is designed to make you afraid.

Thursday, March 16, 2023

The Language of Paradox and the Rhetoric of Drugs

 "I'm a better writer than you ever will be." Such a statement serves two purposes. The first is to puff "me" up. The second is to tear you down. It's a double pill, you see. It makes me bigger by making you smaller. It empowers me by disempowering you.

Now, the "truth value" of the statement is zero. I cannot prove that you will never one day eclipse my talent. In fact, I hope you do. 

Back to that statement. It's function is to produce a feeling. A good one for "me" and a bad one for "you". It therefore, functionally operates like a drug. It cures an ill in the speaker. The speaker does not feel as though they are as good as the spoken. Hence, why they must say that. And thus, the utterance literally implies its opposite or, if not, the speaker's own attitude toward themselves.

So, the Rhetoric of Drugs can be characterized thusly:

  • It produces a feeling
  • It has no truth value
  • It's function is strategic
  • It implies the opposite of what it says
Holistically, we must consider the rhetoric self-refuting because we know the utterance is meant to make the speaker feel the opposite of how they currently feel while passing on the speaker's baggage to the spoken.

What desire produces this?

You can ask yourself this question every time you read something. So, we know exactly what desire produces the aforementioned speech. But, "I am the virgin and the whore." What desire produces that speech? The Thunder, Perfect Mind is a Gnostic text written from the perspective a mother deity called Sophia. The text would likely have been read in front of groups of women by a skilled performer in an act of group hypnosis. What sorts of baggage do women carry around with them due to Biblical masculinity? 

The purpose is therapeutic. While one utterance is vampirism, the other is convalescent. Beyond that, it collapses the duality of this being better than that. And that too is therapeutic. 

Think about this in terms of Game Theory. If Sophia says, "I'm a virgin." It shames all those who are not virgins. If Sophia says, "I'm a big ole slut," it places promiscuity on a pedestal that will make some women uncomfortable. Hence, she is both and holds the opposites in abeyance. 

So, rhetorically and psychologically, the language of paradox is the language of wholeness. It's a linguistic drug meant to produce a state of wholeness. It may not work right away, but I see the merit to this approach. 

ChatGPT analyzes the "Rhetoric of Drugs"

This article discussed the Rhetoric of Drugs, focusing on the power of language and its ability to manipulate emotions and create certain feelings. Here, we will analyze this concept from different perspectives not covered in the article, such as sociolinguistics, philosophy of language, and neuroscientific approaches.

Sociolinguistics perspective:

From a sociolinguistics standpoint, the Rhetoric of Drugs can be examined through the lens of how language is used within different social contexts and its impact on interpersonal relationships. People may use language strategically to assert power or maintain their social position, with the intention to manipulate others' perceptions and emotions. The article's examples can be expanded to consider how different social groups, cultural backgrounds, or even generational gaps might influence the use of such rhetoric in various settings.

Philosophy of language perspective:

From the philosophy of language perspective, the Rhetoric of Drugs can be analyzed in terms of meaning, reference, and truth. The article points out that this kind of rhetoric often has no truth value. This can be further explored by considering how language users might rely on context, implicature, and presuppositions to convey meaning beyond the literal interpretation of their words. This perspective can shed light on how paradoxical language or metaphors can create an impact on listeners even when their literal meanings might not hold any truth value.

Neuroscientific perspective:

A neuroscientific approach to the Rhetoric of Drugs could examine the cognitive and emotional processes that underlie the impact of such rhetoric. For instance, the use of emotionally charged language, paradoxes, and rhetorical strategies might engage different brain regions, such as the amygdala or prefrontal cortex, which are known to be involved in emotional processing and decision-making. This perspective can help us understand the neural mechanisms that make language such a powerful tool for influencing people's feelings and behaviors.

Educational perspective:

From an educational perspective, the Rhetoric of Drugs can be seen as a valuable topic for teaching critical thinking and media literacy. By understanding how language can be used to manipulate emotions and beliefs, students can develop the skills necessary to evaluate the credibility of information and resist the influence of deceptive rhetoric. Educators can use examples from the article to illustrate the importance of questioning the intent behind language use and recognizing the potential impact of rhetoric on their own emotions and decision-making.

These additional perspectives can provide a more comprehensive understanding of the Rhetoric of Drugs, emphasizing the multifaceted nature of language and its influence on individuals and society.

Useful Bibliography

  • The Aesthetic of the Good Physician/Self-Consuming Artifacts, Stanley Fish
  • Freud "On Negation"
  • Lcercle again is very useful
  • "The Thunder, Perfect Mind"


Data Alignment/Similarity/Difference

It's not a secret anymore that my approach to poetics is confusion. But, it's a very intentional confusion and a confusion that gets consistent results. What do I mean? The concept of data alignment in computer programming refers to a system of aligning variables such that you do not need to take a circuitous route to get to them. 

In other words, you want to make the call in as few steps as possible. This requires some forethought, but it improves speed, reduces the number of steps, and is ultimately necessary in the economy of the processor. 

In brain terms, I think the same thing can be accomplished, but it's very difficult to describe or explain. It operates easier by demonstration.

What my poetics is concerned with, beyond Blake, is a kind of data alignment that produces better thinking. In other words, when we're thinking about a processor, we still want to be thinking about an "economy". But we also want to think about the unique characteristics of the processor and all the differences between a human economy and the limited processing space of a computer. Some of the same rules will apply, of course, because economics is interested in how finite resources are managed. Resource management is an aspect of the computer too. We can therefore apply some optimization techniques to the economy that work on the processor.

That is fundamentally the type of thinking that I want to advocate for.

Sunday, March 12, 2023

Wu Wei Wu and the Art of Writing

 I firmly believe that individuals are attracted to philosophies. We seek out information that helps us and adapt information that improves our lives. These become beliefs. While some of us may be naturally resistant to believing, we still employ belief by necessity. In fact, it would be very hard to get anything done if you didn't believe it was worth the effort. We can resist common modes of believing all we like, reject the paradigm beliefs of our inherited culture, and yet we're never "beyond" belief. Ultimately, even a belief that belief itself is limiting is itself a belief.

Logic isn't necessarily going to want to play fair with the space we're in. We come to rely on it, believe in it, but there is a point of failure. 

Wu Wei Wu is a concept from Taoism that traditionally translated to "non-doing" but today is more explicitly translated as "doing non-doing". Without getting into the details, we'll be assuming the following: "doing non-doing" equals doing without thinking about doing. In other words, it means doing by muscle memory. Let's also posit that "doing non-doing" is better than "doing without consideration" or "doing without training". Indeed, training is mandatory to "do non-doing".

Usually.

In some cases, a beginner may perfectly execute something they're trying. The Zen tradition calls this "beginner's luck" and there has been careful thought paid to "a beginner's mind". A beginner enters the matter with no preconceptions. The beginner does whatever instinctive thing they're going to do, and it looks like they've been doing it all their life. This phenomenon is understood in the Eastern Tradition. It's actually foundational.

Taoism spoke to me in a way that other philosophies did not. I would say that a lot of my early work came from a Taoist perspective. But I did not want to be a writer who could only produce work from one perspective. I wanted to be a writer who was supple enough to actively write from multiple perspectives. Thankfully, Taoism provided a great foundation to "make myself small enough" and "void my preconceptions" well enough to enter into those spaces.

Along my journey, I found writers like Borges and Blake who seemed to thrive in these spaces. They were Western writers, like me, who could help me see more than I saw before. In the case of Blake, it was more. In the case of Borges, it was more clearly. In the case of Taoism, Blake, Zen, and Borges, it was better. 

The Thunder, Perfect Mind

The Thunder, Perfect Mind is a Gnostic text written from the perspective of the Aeon Sophia (Wisdom). The text is a litany of "I am" statements followed by apparent contradictions. As an example, "I am the virgin and the whore." This would be similar to Jesus saying, "I am the Alpha and the Omega." Why is this happening?

To follow the logic of Lecercle, the subject is emerging from a lesser psychological state into a more mature one. Paradoxical language is a flag of this kind of emergence. If it doesn't prove the emergence has happened, it proves the emergence is beginning to happen. Jung also spoke of uniting opposites and Fish speaks of a place beyond opposition that is the domain of the Good Physician. The Good Physician withholds judgment and renders care. The Good Physician is, of course, a Christlike figure.

Christ, of course, is not a name, but a title meaning annointed. There were those who believed Christ was fulfilment of the Jewish Bible, others who believed Christ was a sage who had attained a certain degree of spiritual maturity, and still others who believed Christ and Jesus were two separate entities and Jesus "had" this Christ spirit or daemon within him until he was crucified. There were a lot of different ways of thinking about Christ, but Christ's use of paradoxical language that employs a type of reflexive logic is notable and consistent. We will see it elsewhere in the Eastern Tradition, especially Zen and Taoism, where negative and positive are considered equally and simultaneously. The last point is where the leveling up occurs. The brain rejects efforts to think using both opposites simultaneously, but permits dialectical efforts quite well. Ultimately, Western philosophers like Heraclitus also seem to permit this sort of paradoxical and contradictory thinking. 

Wednesday, March 8, 2023

The Script

 No metaphor is quite as potent for me as "the script". It's a tri-figured metaphor that carries the entirety of every reference it subsumes. In this case, there are three senses of the "script" and each one is integral to the poetry you'll find on these blogs. 

  1. The script as a sequence of instructions in code, or program, computer code, or simply script. It's a machine.
  2. The script as in a play. The script is a blueprint for producing a play. It is a template on which all future performances will be based. It is as perfect a blueprint as you can conceive. The play exists outside of time and is incarnated into a performance.
  3. The script as in a prescription. The prescription, following Fish, treats language as a drug that is meant to provoke some kind of wellness, to restore a person to a state of wellness, or to remove an illness. 
Within the English word "script" is a composite metaphor that is about as perfect for writers as I can imagine and it's heavily influenced every aspect of my construction process. 


Wednesday, March 1, 2023

How I Got Here, A Poetical Journey

 I have two main skills. I can write. I can program. I was interested in language poetry. Language poetry stresses different ways of generating language from language, emphasizes language as both subject and object, and de-emphasizes meaning. There were times when language poetry appeared to be struggling against meaning, but others when it felt saturated in meaning. Like the words alone weren't enough to hold the amount of meaning in the poem. I was interested fundamentally in the latter. My instinct toward producing this effect was always compression. I also like to torture metaphors until they've provided all of their meaning. Those are just funny little things I do. Style stuff. Instincts. Probably the product of some combination of neuroses and mental illness. Definitely the sort of thing I want to cling to and identify myself with.

So, language generating language. I wrote the first text generator as a template generator that could also operate on tags, call mini-dictionaries, and other stuff. The second generator included ngram generation which I added later. Natural language and ngram generation are both considered a part of AI. Further efforts improved both template and ngram generation but it was never more than either/or. Attempts to hybridize the two met with really random results. I've been doing this for over a decade, so imagine my surprise when it became bad.

At this point, I'm pretty old. Any positive headway my personality was going to make either I already made or deemed it not worth making. I don't have patience for bullshit, wankers, or wanker bullshit. I just don't. I've built ngram algorithms from the ground up, wrote my own coding language, and certainly know how to write. So, I don't need to justify myself to anyone who thinks their poetry can be replaced by text generation. I don't.

Now, here's the secret sauce. What I do can never be replaced. Not by AI, not by my clone, not if I ran an acolyte-producing bootcamp. I can't be replaced. While any single poem can accidentally be reproduced by another poet given a similar set of circumstances, the totality of my work, the effort I made, the way I evolved my craft all grew out of an environment that I participated in. An AI fed the same data wouldn't have the same human needs as me. It can only mimic me. Which is fun. Anyone can mimic you. Why is it suddenly terrifying because it's a machine? 

So, that the point is driven home, if I was reborn again, perhaps 40 years ago, whatever I produced would be very different. I can't even replace myself. So, the idea of worrying about these things reeks of a kind of insecurity and small-mindedness I associate with very young people who have overestimated the novelty of their contributions. 

I don't know what to tell you, guys. I've literally never had this problem. I consider being able to recognize great poetry a poetic act. Being able to see why it works when it works requires a poetic act. Making poems is just a part of that. To me, it's all part of one big thing that's a life experience. So, the idea that it can be taken from me is not within the realm of possibility. To me, it's a gift I share with people. You can feed my language into a generator, but you can't feed me into a generator. Even if you could, I'd be okay with that. Sounds awesome. Sign me up.






Tuesday, February 28, 2023

L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E Poetics, corporations are gods, language has an agency

 My introduction to L=A=N=G=U=A=G=E poetry was a class I took with Karen Mac Cormack. There's a lot you can say about L-poetics, but language to these poets was material like paint or clay. Meaning trapped and limited poets so constructing a poem from the starting point of meaning often led to blocks. It seems extremely practical to me. Eventually, everyone runs out of things to say. So, different ways to use text as stuff was a great way to think about language and poetics.

I was less enthusiastic about ascribing an agency to language, but, perhaps that was due to my own psychological baggage. It's more obvious to me than almost anything else than language has more agency in this world than human beings. I don't even know if this is a bad thing. When you think of religion as a social language with specific social functions, you start to think of other things as language that serve other functions. Suddenly, almost any organized group is a language including companies and corporations. How did we get here? Well, the articles of incorporation are essentially a script for instantiating the corporate object. It's a legal object. Every new corporation inherits the properties of the corporate object. It's that simple. Governments have constitutions. It's language generating language. We create myths and stories around it. Language generating language. Going all the way back to the local deities of the Near Eastern traditions. Our governments and states and social organization was inextricably tied to religion and even in some cases, gods. State governments inherit federal laws. Local municipalities inherit state laws. 

Language did have an agency in the creepiest possible way and there may not only be no escape from it, but it may be better than what we had before. Consider that our own personal motivations tend to taint the objective of the law or corrupt our motivations. We want to avoid that, right? The script appears to prevent some forms of corruption while allowing others.

A corporation is a legal document. It's language. It borrows the will of potentially millions of people to function. That's why it's a god. And like a god, it's more important than a person. 

So, the idea of language generating language is not unusual. In some ways, it's a performance of the relative loss of humanity that occurs in modern bureaucracies, ancient bureaucracies, and to humans living under human systems. 

Sunday, February 26, 2023

The purpose of meaning

 The interplay between a text and an interpreter creates a chemistry all its own. A chemistry that can be profound for one person can fall flat for another. Something that's beautiful to one person will be ugly to another. Something that can feel empowering to one person can be traumatizing to another. The interplay and politics of this experience is so vast and unpredictable, that the only way it can go wrong is every single time it happens.

Ultimately, the human experience is humiliating, terrifying, traumatizing, exhilarating, satisfying, inspiring, and every other label you could think of. 

Poets will relate to their own work their own way. For me, my poetics is a tool. Sort of a map, maybe. Not everyone benefits from inherited societal values. A poetics of rebellion provides a roadmap against inherited systems of meaning. There will be some people who always need this. I needed this when writers like Blake entered my life. 

The escape from your reason 

My willingness to accept your meaning as valuable has to be related to its capacity to help, limit, grow, or destroy me. If it limits me, then I must transcend it. If destroys me, then I must escape it and fight it. If it isn't helping me grow or (at the very least) not preventing me from achieving growth, then it should be opposed and replaced. Ultimately, setting your own standards is psychologically healthy, philosophically useful, but negatively reinforced and even punished in most systems.

The escape from your meaning

I must create a system or be enslaved by another man's. That was Blake's justification. I don't think I needed one. Whatever brought me here was north of any specific intention I may have had. It was closer to compulsion. Escaping from your meaning, however, leaves me with a problem. I can either end up in a void where there is no meaning, or suffer the strain of creating it for myself. Alternatively, I can align myself with those who ventured the effort, or salad bar their efforts as part of an allegedly-cohesive whole. 

Once you're here, it has to meet your needs.

Escaping meaning itself

Even those who live lives of debauchery believe that their lives are more meaningful because of the debauchery they enjoy. No one escapes meaning until they're brain dead or in a pine box. That is different than saying their ability to make meaning is functioning properly. This, I suspect, is when suicide occurs. While animals in the wild may stop eating and otherwise allow themselves to die, they do not tie ropes around their necks, cut their own throats, or commit any active violence against themselves as far as I know. This is what happens when our ability to make our lives meaningful is destroyed. 

What does it all mean?

By the time you're asking that question, no one can answer it for you. That is to say, if you don't know, no one can tell you an answer that's guaranteed to satisfy you. But along your way, you'll find those who needed to embark on the same journey and they'll leave records behind. And you can see how they approached the matter and take what's important for you and leave the rest, like a great salad bar of poetical rebellion.

Ultimately, meaning has to stay because it's awful hard to motivate yourself without a reason.

Saturday, February 25, 2023

Via negativa

 So, I'm reading a book called The History of Negation, that touches on some interesting themes. It is far more common in Western philosophy to privilege positive facts over negative facts. While there is no great impulse in Eastern philosophy to privilege negative facts over positive facts, there are occasions in which it's emphasized. These occasions were formative for me.

To date, there is no one who says we should privilege negative facts over positive facts. However, there are some who believe they are equally valuable. Where could such a notion come from? The Tao Te Ching.

“Thirty spokes converge at the hub,
but emptiness completes the wheel.
Clay is shaped to make a pot,
and what’s useful is its emptiness.
Carve fine doors and windows,
but the room is useful in its emptiness.
What is
is beneficial, while what is not
also proves useful.”

Achieving a balance between the positive and the negative is the goal of Taoism. Analytically, however, we can get into some weirdness. The cup and where it isn't, that is to say, the empty space that holds the liquid, doesn't "exist" in a traditional sense of is-ness. Perhaps you can formulate a way to make it fit, but you have an absence that is carried with the cup wherever you take it. That absence is created or derived from the presence of the cup. In Western ontology, the dependent variable is considered a child-variable. Eastern ontology may not differ all that much, but we have Zen and Taoism which consider the issue of balance. However, if we ascribe is-ness to an absence, we run the risk of paradox.

We may have already run into a paradox. Because if our desire for a cup is the cause of it's making, then the empty space predates the cup and hence, derivative to the need for making it, the desire for it, the lack of it. One negative space gives birth to another, and both are more useful than the cup itself which can be reduplicated indefinitely now. The power that gave birth to the cup is the desire for the cup and the ingenuity it took to produce the cup. These are primary to the cup itself. The cup is derived from this. So, the fact of the cup, it's positive existence, may not necessarily deserve its place of privilege.

Perhaps, the negative facts, lacks, and desires are all related to our human existence in a way that is genuinely more important than positive facts. Maybe not. We don't want to replace one mistake with another. Nonetheless, there is a case to make. It's bizarre that it's so infrequently made.